I
Correspondência (mestrados e doutoramentos)
Jorge Vala e Anália Torres (org.): Contextos e Atitudes Sociais na Europa , Lisboa, ICS, 2007
II. Ainda Tony Judt
Ontem no Guardian , o Keith Flett, “Convenor” do London Socialist Historians Group (1993) e autor de “The Twentieth Century: A Century of Wars and Revolutions “[ed. with David Renton, 2000] e “Chartism After 1848 : The Working Class and the Politics of Radical Education ( Merlin Press, 2005), fez publicar a seguinte nota : “ Your obituary of Tony Judt (9 August) focuses on his landmark, book-length, contributions to history, but skates over a much shorter piece which proved a defining moment in left historiography. His view on where social history was going, A Clown in Regal Purple, was published in History Workshop Journal 7 in 1979 and provoked a furious response. Judt argued that new directions in social history, some, though not all, of which represented the beginnings of the postmodern turn in the subject, represented an unworthy drift from the prevailing class-based analysis.
Ironically, while not all of Judt's criticism was warranted – there were important new areas and approaches for social historians to explore – the furious reaction seemed to create a certain distance between himself and the left, which he had been attempting to defend, and certainly defined his career path after that time.” [The Guardian, Wednesday 11 August 2010]
Flett fez muito bem em evocar a relevância historiográfica de “A Clown in Regal Purple: Social History and the Historians” [ in History Workshop Journal , OUP, 1979; 7: 66-94] para a definição do “marxismo académico“ europeu no campo da História e 0 seu distanciamento face à fragmentação da História Social e inclusive à “viragem cultural”, ao relativismo e pósmodernismo emergentes. Pode ter-se uma visão geral do debate suscitado em Adrian Wilson [Rethinking Social History: English society 1570-1920 and its interpretation, 1995[ cap. 1- “A Critical Portrait of social History”] e encontrar marc as relevantes dos “ataques” dirigidos ao texto de Tony Judt , como os de Edward Shorter e David Levine, em Theory and Society Volume 9, Number 5, Special Issue on Social History 1980.HAF